Picking the Right Lock for Your Door
Every lock trades a little security for a little convenience, and the door has a say too. A keyed deadbolt, a keypad and a mortise lock each do the job well on the right door and poorly on the wrong one. Here’s how six common types compare.
Deadbolts, Keypads and Levers Side by Side
Read each row with your own door in mind. Any of these locks is only as strong as the frame and the strike plate it closes into.
Scroll the table sideways for more.
| Lock type | Best for | Security notes | How it’s operated | Things to consider |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Standard keyed deadbolt | Front and back doors of houses and apartments | A solid bolt that can’t be slipped like a spring latch; its strength depends on the strike plate and its screws | A key outside, a thumb turn inside | Can be rekeyed when keys go missing; keep count of the copies |
| High-security cylinder | Shops, offices, rentals and any door where key control matters | Built to resist picking, bumping and drilling; keys are often restricted, so copies need the owner’s say-so | A key, in a deadbolt or a commercial lock | Spare keys come through the key system, not a hardware counter, so plan ahead for copies |
| Keypad deadbolt | Side and garage doors, rentals, and households where keys go missing | As strong as the deadbolt it’s built on; a code is only as private as the people who know it | A code outside, a thumb turn inside, with a backup key | Batteries need changing; change the code when someone moves out, and now and then anyway |
| Smart lock | Households that let people in from afar or want a record of comings and goings | Usually the same bolt as a deadbolt; the app and the account need a strong passcode and regular updates | A phone app over Bluetooth or Wi-Fi, often a keypad too, plus a backup key | Batteries, app updates and a Wi-Fi signal at the door; keep the backup key where you can reach it |
| Lever handle set | Inside doors, and anyone who finds a round knob hard to grip | A spring latch, not a deadbolt; on an outside door, pair it with a deadbolt | Press the lever down; a button or a key locks it | Easy with full or sore hands; often called for on doors open to the public |
| Mortise lock | Older commercial doors and some older homes, like Orlando’s 1920s bungalows with their original doors | A heavy lock body set into a pocket in the door’s edge, often with the latch and the deadbolt in one case | A key outside, a thumb turn or a key inside, a knob or lever for the latch | Parts fit that lock body, so a repair often beats a swap; changing to a standard deadbolt usually means a cover plate or a wood patch over the pocket |
If the lock you have is sound and the only trouble is who has a key, you may not need a new type at all. A rekey sets new pins and keeps the hardware you have.
Switching types, like a knob to a lever set or a spring latch to a deadbolt, is lock installation work. The door gets a say there: its thickness, its edge and the holes already in it decide what fits.
Keypads and app-run deadbolts bring questions of their own, from batteries to Wi-Fi at the door, and the answers decide which smart lock suits you.
Choosing Between Keys and Codes
These are the trade-offs that usually decide it.
- Is a keypad deadbolt as strong as a keyed one?
Where it counts, often yes: a good keypad deadbolt throws the same kind of bolt into the same strike plate. The difference is the code. It can be shared, guessed from worn buttons or forgotten, so pick one that isn’t a birthday or your house number, and change it now and then.
- Should I pick a smart lock or a plain keypad?
A keypad is enough if all you want is to stop carrying keys. A smart lock earns its place if you want to let people in from your phone, see when the door was opened, or, on many models, hand out codes that only work on certain days. Those extras bring app updates and a Wi-Fi signal at the door to think about.
- Which is better for a rental, a keypad or a keyed lock?
A keypad saves chasing keys at every move-out: set a new code and the old one stops working, though the backup key still needs watching. A keyed lock is simpler and has nothing to charge, and a rekey between tenants gives the same clean start. Some landlords put a keypad on the main door and keep keyed locks everywhere else.
- Does a high-security cylinder make sense on a house?
It can. If you’ve had a break-in, keep valuables at home, or hand out keys you want to stay in control of, a cylinder that resists picking and drilling, with keys nobody can copy at a hardware counter, is worth a look. For most front doors, a solid deadbolt with a sturdy strike plate does the job.
Match a Lock to Your Household
Answer for the door you’re thinking about. Got more than one door in mind? Run it once for each.
Lock Picker
Three questions about the door, who uses it and what matters most, then two lock types worth a closer look.
Choose your answers, then press Show My Picks.
Have a door in mind? We’ll help you pick the lock that suits it.